A sharp retreat in fuel prices is giving some analysts a reason to question the Federal Reserve’s push toward further interest-rate increases. The concern is not that inflation has returned to the central bank’s target. Rather, the analysts say, recent declines in energy and commodity prices may be sending a different signal from the broad price pressures captured in October’s inflation reports, according to CoinDesk.
The challenge comes as Fed officials weigh their next move after holding rates at 3.75% to 4% at their October 27–28 meeting. The decision passed 10–2, with Lisa Cook and Beth Hammack favoring an immediate quarter-point increase. Minutes released November 18 showed that almost all participants expected further increases would likely be appropriate under their baseline outlooks. The next meeting is scheduled for December 8–9.
Officials have differed over how forcefully to proceed. Governor Christopher Waller argued on November 18 for either a half-point increase in December or a quarter-point move with a credible signal of another increase in January, Reuters reported. He was concerned about inflation spreading into services and affecting public expectations. Bloomberg reported that New York Fed President John Williams said a day earlier that the situation did not require dramatic action, while acknowledging more work was needed to reach 2% inflation.
A fuel signal ahead of inflation reports
Arvy co-founder Thierry Borgeat’s argument centers on the timing of the information available to policymakers. He views inflation reports as lagging indicators and refining margins as a more forward-looking measure. His concern is that the Fed could tighten just as lower fuel prices begin reaching consumers. That distinction matters to the critique: the October reports showed broad pressures, but the energy-market declines described by the analysts are more recent.
One measure in focus is the 3-2-1 crack spread, an approximation of the margin from turning three barrels of crude oil into two barrels of gasoline and one of diesel. Citing Wellington Altus strategist James Thorne, CoinDesk reported that the spread had fallen to $41.90 a barrel from $65.56 over the six weeks through November 18. It is a refining-margin indicator, rather than a direct measure of what drivers pay at the pump.
Thorne attributed the narrowing margin to strong refinery output and abundant fuel supplies, not weak demand. In his account, gasoline and diesel prices were dropping faster than crude prices. He also cautioned that changes at the wholesale level can take weeks to reach motorists, leaving a gap between the prices seen in fuel markets and the bills consumers encounter at service stations.
Wholesale gasoline futures had already registered several steep declines. CoinDesk’s analysis of TradingView data showed losses of 11.1% and 6.1% in the previous two completed weeks, followed by another 4.4% decline so far in the week of its November 19 report. The roughly 20% drop across that three-week span was the steepest since March 2020. The latest weekly figure was still in progress when reported.
Pump prices and the inflation outlook
Drivers were also seeing lower prices, although gasoline remained more expensive than a year earlier. The AAA national average for regular gasoline was $3.75 a gallon on November 19, according to CoinDesk. That was 12.8% below its level a month earlier and 4.9% lower than the previous week, but still about 22% higher than a year before. Those comparisons show why a recent decline in fuel costs is different from a return to earlier price levels.
Thorne estimated that a 10-cent drop in gasoline prices subtracts about nine basis points from headline consumer-price inflation. He anticipated that the monthly headline reading could turn negative in November and said an earlier war-related price spike would fall out of annual comparisons in March. Both points concern the outlook for inflation calculations; the negative monthly reading was a possibility he anticipated, not an announced result.
The retreat was not confined to gasoline. Through November 18, Carson Investment Research strategist Ryan Detrick tracked month-to-date declines of 20.9% for gasoline fund UGA, 19.4% for crude fund USO and 12.5% for copper fund CPER. Natural-gas fund UNG moved in the other direction, rising 16.9%. The figures describe the funds’ performance, and CoinDesk cautioned that futures-based funds can differ from spot commodity prices.
For now, the analysts’ timing argument sits alongside expectations of more tightening rather than an established change in Fed policy. In its November 19 report, CoinDesk said interest-rate futures implied quarter-point increases in December and January, with another by April. Those were market expectations, not decisions by the central bank. The October minutes also showed that two participants thought a December move larger than a quarter point could be appropriate if incoming inflation data warranted it.
