THE DESK.Markets, in focus
crypto   News

Another appellate court rules against Kalshi as legal pressure builds

A divided Fourth Circuit left Maryland regulators able to pursue enforcement against Kalshi, adding to a patchwork of court decisions and federal regulatory demands.

By The Desk Newsroom   ·   4 min read · Published

Updated

Editorial illustration for Another appellate court rules against Kalshi as legal pressure builds

Kalshi has suffered another appellate setback in its fight over state oversight of prediction markets. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit sided with Maryland in a 2-1 decision, agreeing that the state may apply its sports-wagering laws to the company, CoinDesk reported on November 18. The decision adds to a series of disputes over whether federal supervision of event contracts displaces state gambling rules.

The immediate question before the court was narrower than the entire dispute. Kalshi had appealed a lower-court judge’s refusal to issue an injunction stopping Maryland regulators from pursuing enforcement, according to Reuters. The appellate loss leaves the state able to pursue that enforcement; it does not establish that every issue in the broader case has been finally resolved. For Kalshi, the result means the requested shield against state action remains out of reach in this case.

A divided court and competing views of the contracts

The case grew out of a 2025 cease-and-desist letter in which Maryland regulators demanded that Kalshi stop offering what they considered unlicensed sports wagering. Kalshi sued, arguing that federal derivatives regulation superseded state gambling oversight. The disagreement puts the legal classification of its sports contracts at the center of the case: Maryland’s position would allow it to enforce wagering rules, while Kalshi has argued for federal authority to prevail.

The judges who sided with Maryland reached their conclusions through separate opinions. Judges Roger Gregory and Stephanie Thacker both found that the contracts could remain subject to state gaming law, though their reasoning differed. Gregory emphasized that gambling regulation has traditionally been a state power and that Congress had not clearly displaced Maryland’s authority. Kalshi pointed to the three separate opinions as evidence of inconsistent judicial reasoning against prediction markets.

Judge DeAndrea Benjamin dissented, taking a different view of the products and their regulator. Reuters reported that she regarded Kalshi’s sports-event contracts as swaps, a category of derivatives she said fell exclusively under Commodity Futures Trading Commission oversight. Her position illustrates the division within the panel over how the contracts fit into federal law, even as the majority’s result permits Maryland to pursue enforcement.

The products at issue are tied to sports outcomes. At oral argument on May 7, examples then available on Kalshi included yes-or-no contracts on an Orioles game and on whether the Ravens would win their division, the Baltimore Sun reported. Gregory questioned how such products differed from gambling. Those examples show why the dispute has drawn state gaming regulators into a debate that Kalshi frames around federal derivatives oversight.

State protections meet federal access demands

Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown said the outcome means Kalshi must meet the consumer-protection standards applied to other sportsbooks serving state residents. He identified requirements involving customer-data protection, deceptive advertising and marketing to people barred from betting or vulnerable to gambling harm. Maryland gaming commission acting director Jeremy Baker separately welcomed the ruling as an affirmation of state authority over activity he considered sports wagering.

The Fourth Circuit decision also joins a broader split among appeals courts. Reuters reported that two other appellate courts had ruled against Kalshi, while another concluded that New Jersey could not regulate the company in the relevant proceedings. On September 25, the Sixth Circuit ruled against Kalshi in consolidated Ohio and Tennessee disputes, finding that the company had not shown its sports contracts were swaps and that federal commodities law did not preempt those states’ gambling laws.

That judicial landscape contrasts with a separate federal regulatory demand. On November 6, CoinDesk reported that the CFTC had given regulated exchanges 30 days to restore access in restricted regions or explain why doing so was not feasible, despite court orders requiring restrictions in some jurisdictions. Before the Maryland decision, Kalshi customers in Nevada, Washington and Michigan had already been geographically blocked while the company contested local restrictions.

The federal directive has drawn political opposition as well. On November 16, Senate Democrats asked the CFTC to withdraw it, arguing that it conflicted with active court orders. The agency shares Kalshi’s position that federally regulated event contracts fall under exclusive federal jurisdiction. The conflicting appellate decisions increase the possibility of Supreme Court review, according to Reuters, though they do not guarantee it.

Sources & reporting notes

  1. Another U.S. appellate court goes against Kalshi, building the industry's legal headwinds
    CoinDesk · Reported Nov 18, 2026, 7:33 PM ET · Retrieved Nov 18, 2026, 8:00 PM ET
  2. Kalshi loses bid to prevent Maryland from policing prediction market
    Yahoo Finance · Reported Publication date not specified · Retrieved Nov 18, 2026, 8:00 PM ET
  3. Maryland fights Kalshi sports contracts in court
    Yahoo Finance · Reported Publication date not specified · Retrieved Nov 18, 2026, 8:00 PM ET
  4. Appeals court rules against Kalshi, says prediction markets can be regulated like gambling
    Yahoo Finance · Reported Publication date not specified · Retrieved Nov 18, 2026, 8:00 PM ET
  5. U.S. prediction markets regulator issues demand that clashes directly with courts
    CoinDesk · Reported Publication date not specified · Retrieved Nov 18, 2026, 8:00 PM ET
  6. U.S. Senate Democrats tell CFTC to back off its demand prediction markets defy bans
    CoinDesk · Reported Publication date not specified · Retrieved Nov 18, 2026, 8:00 PM ET

For information only. Not investment advice. Investing involves risk, including loss of principal.

More crypto news →